Worst Starting Quarterback in Super Bowl History

[JR2004]

Who is the worst starting Quarterback in SB History?

Joe Kapp Minnesota Vikings SB IV
Vince Ferragamo Los Angeles Rams SB XIV
David Woodley Miami Dolphins SB XVII
Tony Eason New England Patriots SB XX
Jeff Hostetler New York Giants SB XXV
Stan Humphries San Diego Chargers SB XXIX
Rex Grossman Chicago Bears SB XLI
Other

[JJ7997]

Grossman.

[Emerson1]

Grossman will have 4 passes that result in touchdowns.

[neck_06]

Humphries was pretty bad. IMHO you can't be a bad QB and make it to the Super Bowl.

People need to get off Grossman's back, he has had some bad games, but he does what it takes to win. This was his first full season as a starter and he took a team to the Super Bowl.

[Pmoney]

Originally posted by neck_06
Humphries was pretty bad. IMHO you can't be a bad QB and make it to the Super Bowl.

People need to get off Grossman's back, he has had some bad games, but he does what it takes to win. This was his first full season as a starter and he took a team to the Super Bowl.

i agree

[JR2004]

I voted for Kapp myself...Could any of the folks who were actually alive at the time explain how in the world that guy started for a pro football team at all?

[burnet44]

dilfer
hands down

[crzyjournalist03]

Originally posted by Emerson1
Grossman will have 4 passes that result in touchdowns.

to which team???


I voted for Rex, but I was disappointed that Trent Dilfer from XXXV wasn't an option!!!

[burnet44]

as I said lol

[JR2004]

Originally posted by crzyjournalist03
to which team???


I voted for Rex, but I was disappointed that Trent Dilfer from XXXV wasn't an option!!!

I almost put him on there because he was a pretty mediocre quarterback during his career. He might be the worst starting QB to ever trip into winning a Super Bowl. That defense for the Ravens was probably the 2nd best I've seen in my life behind the 85 Bears.

[bobcat1]

Originally posted by burnet44
dilfer
hands down

That was my first thought!

[tigerpride_08]

im to young to know any of these QB's besides Grossman...

[JJ7997]

At least Dilfer knew he sucked. Grossman just takes credit for his teams wins and gives his rediculous post game speaches about how he dont care how they win. I will get all kinds of hate for my dogging of the Bears, but I dont care. They aint good. To heck with the NFC, they should just liquidate the entire NFC !

[AggieJohn]

where's phil's input into this category

[88bobcats]

What about Fran Tarkington and Jim Kelly?

I'll grant you that these two quarterbacks were, in general, better than the others on the poll list; but they each had four chances and never won the big game. Of course, despite the final score, I thought the Bills beat the Giants that first time in '91.

Tarkington and Kelly obviously had the game skills, but, especially in the pros, the starting QB is a leader and sets a tone for the team; and their teams went 0-for-4.