The argument for Bellville over Caddo Mills is I think Bellville is flat out better....Padilla has Bellville as 15 point favorite over Caddo and Jerry has Bellville as a 17 point favorite over Caddo Mills so I think my eye test combined with both major computer rankings makes that plausible
By the way I do the the 4A rankings and Tepper and co review and make any changes suggestions they see fit...
I think in D2 they've been pretty solid rankings...D1 up until last week was super chalky as well