Romo for Cutler?

[Bullaholic]

Saw several articles the past few days exploring the idea of trading Tony Romo for Jay Cutler straight up. What does the 3ADL gang think about this?

[Emerson1]

Jay Cutler has won less then Romo.

JJones just came out and said he let TO go to make it more Romo-friendly

[pirate4state]

He'll look like an even bigger fool if he does this!

As much as Romo drives me nuts, I still think he is our guy.

[waterboy]

No way! That would be the epitome of stupidity to make a trade like that!:mad: Thank God I don't see this trade happening.:hand:

[Farmersfan]

Originally posted by Emerson1
Jay Cutler has won less then Romo.

JJones just came out and said he let TO go to make it more Romo-friendly


Jay Cutler didn't have half the team around him that Romo had and he threw for about 4500 yards and had a rating just 5 points below Romo's last year. Cutler is twice the QB Romo is and before the Cutler acting like a baby incident I would take Cutler over Romo any time any day. But not after I saw his hissy fit. His maturity level is way too low.......

[Emerson1]

How can someone be twice the QB that someone else is when you have a lower QB rating then someone who played games with a broken finger in a splint?

[Bullaholic]

Wonder how seriously everyone took Jerry Jones when he said he wouldn't trade Romo for ANY player in the NFL?

[Maroon87]

If Cutler can't handle criticism or trade rumors in Denver, how on Earth can he handle it in Dallas?

[Trashman]

Originally posted by Emerson1
How can someone be twice the QB that someone else is when you have a lower QB rating then someone who played games with a broken finger in a splint?

I love it! You were saying what I was thinkin!;) :D :devil:

[Txbroadcaster]

this trade really cannot happen

In the NFL now you trade a player you take the cap hit RIGHT then on the bonus money. So Dallas would take the Romo hit, already taking on 10 million in dead money from released players

[IHStangFan]

Originally posted by pirate4state
He'll look like an even bigger fool if he does this!

As much as Romo drives me nuts, I still think he is our guy. WHOA!! WAIT....WHAT?!?! BACK THE TRUCK UP!!! You used to dog the hell outa me about Romo!! LOL. :D

With that said....I don't know that I'd trade him for Cutler.....although it's worth a look I guess. I do wonder though how Cutler would fair w/ the rest of the Cowboys' talent around him.

[solocam]

I would trade him,he sucks in big games

[Diocletian]

This is a good trade for both teams.

I say do it.

[SintonFan_inAustin]

http://img12.imageshack.us/img12/5148/tonyromo2.jpg


Its Romo team and he'll get the job done this next season :flaming:

[Trashman]

Trading Romo for Cutler; No way! Romo is just starting to mature as a QB. The next 5 years should be good ones.:D

[pirate4state]

Originally posted by IHStangFan
WHOA!! WAIT....WHAT?!?! BACK THE TRUCK UP!!! You used to dog the hell outa me about Romo!! LOL. :D

With that said....I don't know that I'd trade him for Cutler.....although it's worth a look I guess. I do wonder though how Cutler would fair w/ the rest of the Cowboys' talent around him. That's cause you are you & I am me! :D


I said he drives me nuts, but only I can talk crap about him. ;)

[LionKing]

Romo is the man, Cutler is a Baby.

[BaTmAn24]

Well now that jerry jones has got most of the drama (T.O.) out of the locker room, they should be just fine with Romo and the receiving core of Roy Williams and Jason Witten. Marion Barber is a BEAST! :cool:

[Bull's-eye]

Originally posted by Farmersfan
Jay Cutler didn't have half the team around him that Romo had and he threw for about 4500 yards and had a rating just 5 points below Romo's last year.

Cutler did have some very good talent around him. I would take Brandon Marshall over any receiver Dallas put on the field last year. Add a promising rookie in Eddie royal, along with Stokely & Scheffler, the Broncos receivers were much better than the Cowboys.

I do have my doubts about Romo, he has cracked under pressure in several big games. He does have the problem of locking in on one receiver and not throwing to the open man. I can still see Martellus Bennett wide open against Pittsburgh, but Romo elected to throw into double coverage.

[Electus Unus]

As of now both are pro bowl quarterbacks. Other than that they are unproven as far as playoffs are concerned. I like Cutler and believe he is a great quarterback who has the potential to be a lot better than Romo. Also I think Romo isn't the answer for the Cowboys.


Originally posted by BaTmAn24
Well now that jerry jones has got most of the drama (T.O.) out of the locker room, they should be just fine with Romo and the receiving core of Roy Williams and Jason Witten. Marion Barber is a BEAST! :cool:

All getting rid of TO did was make it where your team does not have a legitimate #1 receiver. I like Roy Williams a lot but he is no legit #1.

[Farmersfan]

Originally posted by Emerson1
How can someone be twice the QB that someone else is when you have a lower QB rating then someone who played games with a broken finger in a splint?


Well see it works like this. If your team is half as talented then you have to be twice as good as a QB to get to basically the same numbers..........Put Cutler on this Dallas team and Romo on that Bronco team and the difference in numbers would be HUGE! Rome no longer has T.O. to take the blame for his failures so this next season should show everyone. Good or bad we should know the truth.

[Bull's-eye]

Originally posted by Electus Unus
As of now both are pro bowl quarterbacks. Other than that they are unproven as far as playoffs are concerned. I like Cutler and believe he is a great quarterback who has the potential to be a lot better than Romo. Also I think Romo isn't the answer for the Cowboys.

:iagree: I've been following the Cowboys since the early 60's, I too don't think Romo is the answer. I know Owens had his problems, but there were many times Romo missed the open receiver and elected to throw toward Whitten. He does have greater mobility than Cuttler and that is a huge plus with the Cowboys O-line.

[Farmersfan]

Originally posted by Bull's-eye
Cutler did have some very good talent around him. I would take Brandon Marshall over any receiver Dallas put on the field last year. Add a promising rookie in Eddie royal, along with Stokely & Scheffler, the Broncos receivers were much better than the Cowboys.

I do have my doubts about Romo, he has cracked under pressure in several big games. He does have the problem of locking in on one receiver and not throwing to the open man. I can still see Martellus Bennett wide open against Pittsburgh, but Romo elected to throw into double coverage.


Cutlers talent made Marshall a great receiver.

06. (without cutler) 20 rec., 309 yards
07. (with Cutler) 102 rec., 1325 yards
08. (with Cutler) 104 rec., 1265 yards

Eddie Royal was a rookie. Name the last rookie who caught 90 passes for almost 1000 yards? Cutler is a stud at QB. He would turn Austin, Crayton and Hurd into twice the receivers they have been.

[coach]

Originally posted by Farmersfan
Cutlers talent made Marshall a great receiver.

06. (without cutler) 20 rec., 309 yards
07. (with Cutler) 102 rec., 1325 yards
08. (with Cutler) 104 rec., 1265 yards

Eddie Royal was a rookie. Name the last rookie who caught 90 passes for almost 1000 yards? Cutler is a stud at QB. He would turn Austin, Crayton and Hurd into twice the receivers they have been.

marquis colston there i named it

[Bull's-eye]

Originally posted by Farmersfan
Cutlers talent made Marshall a great receiver.

06. (without cutler) 20 rec., 309 yards
07. (with Cutler) 102 rec., 1325 yards
08. (with Cutler) 104 rec., 1265 yards

Eddie Royal was a rookie. Name the last rookie who caught 90 passes for almost 1000 yards? Cutler is a stud at QB. He would turn Austin, Crayton and Hurd into twice the receivers they have been.

Marshall only started one game in 2006, so it probably didn't matter who was the QB. I have watched Marshall and he is a very good receiver, with or without Cutler. I do agree that Cutler would be an upgrade for the Cowboys.

[BIG BLUE DEFENSIVE END]

Please trade Romo for someone...he's terrible.

[crzyjournalist03]

honestly, I think that Cutler and Romo are very similar in both talent and promise.

If I'm the Broncos, I wouldn't take Romo for Cutler straight up.

If I'm the Cowboys, I wouldn't take Cutler for Romo straight up.

[crzyjournalist03]

Originally posted by BIG BLUE DEFENSIVE END
Please trade Romo for someone...he's terrible.

Bring back the days of Quincy Carter and Chad Hutchinson!!!!


At least those teams were overachievers with those leaders behind the helm.

[Farmersfan]

Originally posted by Bull's-eye
Marshall only started one game in 2006, so it probably didn't matter who was the QB. I have watched Marshall and he is a very good receiver, with or without Cutler. I do agree that Cutler would be an upgrade for the Cowboys.


Based on the stats he played 15 games in 06, 16 in 07 and 15 in 08. And I also think he is a very good receiver. But then again I think Cutler would make the 4 Dallas receivers much better also.

[Farmersfan]

Originally posted by coach
marquis colston there i named it


Colston is very good. He caught 70 balls his rookie year for over 1000 yards. I think that was the same year Drew Brees caught on fire as a QB ....... Any correlation? Does the QB make the receiver or does the receiver make the QB?

[mustang04]

Cutler is a little whiney baby who is way too cocky...Romo could be really good but obviously puts being a celebrity before being a quarterback.....both are about as useful as a poopy flavored lolly-pop in some aspect:D

[pirate4state]

Originally posted by mustang04
Cutler is a little whiney baby who is way too cocky...Romo could be really good but obviously puts being a celebrity before being a quarterback.....both are about as useful as a poopy flavored lolly-pop in some aspect:D haha i read poppy and i was thinking, well what's wrong with a poppy lolly-pop :doh: :D it's the weekend woo hoo :wave:

[coach]

Originally posted by BIG BLUE DEFENSIVE END
Please trade Romo for someone...he's terrible.

hell you probably think you could play qb for the cowboys

[Emerson1]

Originally posted by coach
hell you probably think you could play qb for the cowboys
Remember this is the same guy who thinks Jerrod Johnson will be a better college QB then Vince Young.

[BIG BLUE DEFENSIVE END]

Originally posted by coach
hell you probably think you could play qb for the cowboys

No

[Maroon87]

Originally posted by SintonFan_inAustin
http://img12.imageshack.us/img12/5148/tonyromo2.jpg


Its Romo team and he'll get the job done this next season :flaming:

Joe Cotten's!:thumbsup: