Toughest NFL Quarterback

[eagles_victory]

Who is the tought quarterback in the NFL

Favre- consecutive game streak speaks for itself

Rothelisburger- played through so many major injuries and just keeps coming

Peyton Manning- missed 1 play due to injury in his career which has been 8 or 9 years

David Carr- stayed on the field for the most part when the Texans o line was getting him killed

[JasperDog94]

Hands down it's Favre.

[Old Tiger]

Favre. He is an old school QB and doesn't agree with the NFL wussy QB rules.

[JasperDog94]

Originally posted by eagles_victory
David Carr- stayed on the field for the most part when the Texans o line was getting him killed Nice. I needed a good laugh today.:D :D

[kaorder1999]

though manning doesnt seem like a tough guy, he sure as heck never gets hurt...ever

[CenTexSports]

Brett is tough but the painkillers he takes help.

[Adidas410s]

Originally posted by kaorder1999
though manning doesnt seem like a tough guy, he sure as heck never gets hurt...ever

he doesn't get hit much either! ;)

[kaorder1999]

Originally posted by Adidas410s
he doesn't get hit much either! ;)

you are right but when he does get hit he jumps right back up

[Adidas410s]

I would have to throw Steve McNair into the mix for the numerous injuries that he played through back when Tennessee wasn't an afterthought on the schedule....or when half of the downlow posters were still in grade school! ;)

[Stownhorse]

personally I think Mcnabb even though he isnt on there.

[DUKE22]

Originally posted by Adidas410s
I would have to throw Steve McNair into the mix for the numerous injuries that he played through back when Tennessee wasn't an afterthought on the schedule....or when half of the downlow posters were still in grade school! ;) I would agree totally with McNair. I love this guy, it is amazing to watch a QB take off and instead of sliding look to punish someone who tries to tackle him. He is a true warrior, I give the Ravens a shot to make a strong run simply because he is on the feild leading the offense.

[Funk-d-fied]

Stephen McGee hands down

[bobcat1]

Nobody tougher than Favre. I mean good lord that man plays 25% of his games in sub zero wind chills and cold. With the lines he has had to play as long as he has leaves no doubt.


personally I think Mcnabb even though he isnt on there.
He's too fragile.

[GreenMonster]

Originally posted by bobcat1
Nobody tougher than Favre. I mean good lord that man plays 25% of his games in sub zero wind chills and cold. With the lines he has had to play as long as he has leaves no doubt.


Without missing a start in what, 15 years now.

[gobbler grad]

Brett Favre for sure...:thinking:

[Leopards,class of 75]

Originally posted by GreenMonster
Without missing a start in what, 15 years now. Best point yet! And for second place I would have to say Steve McNair even though he was not listed.

[Bearkat]

I feel like you have to go with Carr. That poor guy has been hit more times than Rocky Balboa. He may not be the QB that Favre, or Manning is, but he's one tough SOB.

[Who-dun-it!!?]

Brett Farve not just a QB,

He's a footbal player.
That being said, HANDS DOWN
FARVE!!

[spiveyrat]

I voted for Favre. But Carr gets my sympathy vote.

[big daddy russ]

Carr's getting run over like a two-legged turtle, but he's pretty skiddish nowadays. Can't give the vote to him.

McNair's tougher than PeeWee Herman's palms.

Chrissy Simms ain't Chrissy no more. Anyone who finishes a game with a ruptured anything is alright in my book.

...but my vote went to Favre.

[HM33]

Farve, he is one of the few players that play hard nose, no bull sh! t football (sorry for lang.). Farve is unfortunitly a dieing breed in the NFL.

[DU_stud04]

farve is at the top of tough quarterbacks. peyton manning is right next to him, ive seen him been hit into a pretzel thinking there is no way he'd get up. next play he'd throw for a touchdown. its true, they dont make these breeds of quarterbacks anymore. the new upcoming age is too use to the pansy rules so they dont get hit.

[crzyjournalist03]

How about Tony Romo?

Tony Romo is so tough that he gave Chuck Norris a roundhouse kick to the face.

Tony Romo once took care of Chuck Norris's cats....permanently.

When Chuck Norris goes to sleep every night, he checks his closet to see if Tony Romo is hiding in it!

[BobcatBenny]

Originally posted by Funk-d-fied
Stephen McGee hands down

LMAO :D

[bulldogman06]

Originally posted by crzyjournalist03
How about Tony Romo?

Tony Romo is so tough that he gave Chuck Norris a roundhouse kick to the face.

Tony Romo once took care of Chuck Norris's cats....permanently.

When Chuck Norris goes to sleep every night, he checks his closet to see if Tony Romo is hiding in it!

Tomy Romo hasnt come outta the closet yet?

[bulldogman06]

Oh, and Favre is hands down the toughest qb in the nfl, he loves the game, he is tougher than nails, and he is still really fun to watch

[htowntransplant]

toughest QB = jim "chris" everett...

if u know jim rome, u know what im talking about

nah currently, the toughest QB is favre....no doubt

[big daddy russ]

Originally posted by htowntransplant
toughest QB = jim "chris" everett...

if u know jim rome, u know what im talking about

nah currently, the toughest QB is favre....no doubt
ROFLMAO. That was hilarious. I'm a huge clone, but I have that clip downloaded on my computer. Classic.

[mrescape43]

None of the Above!

Sammy Baugh should be on the list.

The list didn't say "active" so I added this name.

[piratebg]

Favre wins easily.

[big daddy russ]

Originally posted by mrescape43
None of the Above!

Sammy Baugh should be on the list.

The list didn't say "active" so I added this name.
I think Baugh retired two, maybe three years ago.

[mrescape43]

Originally posted by big daddy russ
I think Baugh retired two, maybe three years ago.

I think you are right. :D