Roy Williams or Randy Moss

[mustang04]

who do yall think is better, roy williams (after a few years of experience of course) or randy moss? I have to say Roy myself, he was awesome at UT and he can take hits better than Randy, although Randy did have a better year his rookie year, but i think that's only because there was Carter on the other side and so the secondary wasnt just focusing on Randy at all times, what's yalls take?

[RTX 14]

i dont about who had a better rookie year cause roy's year aint over yet and hes doin dam good at the moment, id have to give it to moss at the moment cause of the experience level, although williams is makin it look easy

[mustang04]

yeah. at this moment moss is better cuz of experience, but thats why i said give williams a few years, he's an awesome receiver

[Phil C]

Roy Williams may be the next Jerry Rice even though probably Jerry will probably have played on teams with more talent.

[BlueBlood]

Randy Moss. However, a receiver is only as good as the QB he plays with.

[tmac]

moss,moss,moss

[BIGGBROTHER]

roy williams much more dominant even in double coverage

[tmac]

no way moss is the best in the league for now and years 2 come

[3afan]

moss - ask again in 2-3 years

[coiled2strike]

.

[JasperDog94]

I'm just glad that I've got both of these receivers in my church fantasy football league.:D :D :D :D

[OldBrahma04]

You can't even compare the 2 yet. Roy has played in what? 4 games... I'm a huge roy williams fan, but as of now the 2 can't be compared.

[WOS1]

Originally posted by OldBrahma04
You can't even compare the 2 yet. Roy has played in what? 4 games... I'm a huge roy williams fan, but as of now the 2 can't be compared.

I agree 100%, once the season is over you can go back and compare their rookie seasons, but right now it's a mute point. Williams, although playing well, is not a focal point yet for defenses. For Moss, defenses are practicing on how to take him away from the offense with double and triple cover packages, and they still haven't had a lot of success stopping him. Moss hasn't had the huge game yet like he's used to, but look what the people around him have done as a result of the defenses concentrating on him. O. Smith, Culpepper and the rest of the receivers are benefitting.

[Flourhead]

someone said a receiver is only as good as his qb.... so would roy be better than moss if they switched teams? williams is bigger and stronger and has a lot of speed and height and ups... basically he's moss + size(as in muscle mass) + stronger - experience...i know moss has cleaned up his attitude a lot but the fact is he's had problems whereas roy hasnt...yet

[Panther Ross]

We all really know who is the best reciever. Marvin Harrison. I promise you.

[flourface]

moss

[52madmidget]

C'mon, give me a break, comparing williams to moss is jumping the gun. Williams is bigger, more humble, breaks his back practicing. Williams is destined to be the better of the two. But whoever said Moss rookie year was better than williams. You got to be a moss fan or a vikings fan. Now me being a hardcore Lions fan, of course I can say Williams. But on talent alone, its still Williams. Wake up watch him run over defenders and maybe people will start to realize the Lions are for real. If they can pull the atlanta game out, they will do well the rest of the year. Now if they can just get a QB who is worth a darn!

[GoDeep]

I dont care if Williams has never played an NFL game, Id still take him over Moss on potential alone.

[H-F RuNnA]

I'm gonna have to go with my boy ROY. I lived in Austin for about 10 years, I have seen lots of his games, and he's a dominater.

[Pball]

If you are talking Fantasy Football numbers then you have to go with Moss since he has the better QB Culpepper.
Down the road I think Williams will be better as Harrington gets more experience.

As far a raw talent I like Williams.

[gobbler grad]

I think Roy is better. Moss is good, but a little to cocky. Roy has the potential to be one heck of a receiver.