What QB would you start your team around Favre or Brady

[just_chunk_it]

i don't know who i would pick

[Keith7]

Brady duh.. Farve is too old

but i would actually go with McNabb if i had to choos any

[shellman54]

depends on what type of team you want.

brady - not flashy, but gets the job done regardless

favre- cannon arm, full of emotion, true warrior

i would pick favre

[cunbed10]

Farve, especially on Madden 05', but my first pick betwix the two would be McNabb, then McNair, then Culpepper, and then Manning. oh they said Farve and Brady, Oops my bad

[handNthedirt]

Gary Hogeboom

[Kool Tarpon 21]

Originally posted by cunbed10
Farve, especially on Madden 05', but my first pick betwix the two would be McNabb, then McNair, then Culpepper, and then Manning. oh they said Farve and Brady, Oops my bad

In that case, I would choose Michael Vick. Just turn off the injuries though. LoL.

[kaorder1999]

brady by far

[SuperFan#1]

Favre - not even close

[pirate4state]

Tom Brady is a STUD in more than one way!! :D :inlove:

[big daddy russ]

If Favre was only 26 (or however old Brady is) Favre would be the no-brainer. Much stronger arm and he just has that fire and that passion that could ignite a young team. As it is, Brady's young so that's who you build the team around.

[Chris Hart]

I'll let the rings do the talking. I'd take Brady. Favre can make great plays, but he also gives up big plays. Brady is as calm of a QB as I've ever seen and he already has one more ring than Favre, and I expect him to get more in the future. Brady is the best QB in the league.

[kaorder1999]

favre is simply too old...now do you mean both qb's in their prime or what?

[PPHSfan]

Is this 3A football?:)

[Gobbler Fan]

Without a doubt Staubauch .......ummmmm Favre in his younger days Brady now.

[eagle08]

I'll take Jake Delhomme....nobody competes like this true cajun boy.

[LH Panther Mom]

Originally posted by handNthedirt
Gary Hogeboom

Oh my gosh - haven't heard that name in a while. ROFL! :D

[LH Panther Mom]

Between Tom Brady & Brett Favre, my pick would be Brady (based on the "hott" factor). ;)